You hear the hopeful sighs among certain Republicans looking to move past Donald Trump and seeing JD Vance mired in quicksand. Maybe Rubio could be the future? He has MAGA credibility but without the cutthroat affect of JD or DeSantis. He was confirmed 99-0 in the Senate. He’s Hispanic. He’s clearly not full MAGA.

Forget it. I say this as someone who would dearly love to see the GOP turn away from Trump and MAGA. But Rubio is not the vehicle. He may not have personally bitten the heads off the chickens, but he enjoyed the meal.

Mona Charen

Mona Charen

Let’s consider the ways in which he has permanently stained his character. And for the sake of space as well as mercy, let’s limit our scope just to Trump’s second term.

Rubio tamely accepted Trump 2.0’s mortifying initial executive orders, including the one Trump signed the day before Rubio took office purporting to rename the Gulf of Mexico the “Gulf of America.” Anyone with a modicum of character would have contradicted his boss and risked the consequences. Trump would probably have taken it well, since it was early in the term and firing his secretary of state over such a matter would have been a bad look, even for him. He might have joked, Marco doesn’t like it. He must love Mexico. But leaving aside Trump’s likely reaction, Rubio had the opportunity to do the right thing but let it pass.

While serving as secretary of state, Rubio also accepted the job as head of the National Archives after Trump summarily fired Colleen Shogan. Her offense was to head up the office that had reported to the Justice Department that Trump had absconded with classified documents when leaving office in 2021 and repeatedly refused to return them. By taking the job, Rubio ratified Trump’s corrupt termination of Shogan (who wasn’t even in charge when the National Archives turned Trump in), as well as his violation of the Espionage Act.

After Signalgate, Rubio accepted the additional job of national security advisor, thus tacitly approving the influence of Laura Loomer, who had gotten most of Mike Waltz’s staff fired and may have played a role in Waltz’s sacking, too. He also ratified the scapegoating of Waltz for Signalgate, and while the former advisor deserved blame, he deserved it no more than Pete Hegseth, Tulsi Gabbard and others of the president’s closest allies and confidants, including Rubio himself. Again, Rubio could have done the right thing but let it pass.

When Elon Musk and his pimple-faced enforcers stormed into USAID to pull funding from immunization programs, close down rural African clinics and cancel food aid to hundreds of thousands of the neediest people on the planet (all in violation of the law), Rubio could have protested. Hell, by then he was head of USAID, too. When Musk tweeted that USAID was a “criminal organization” and that it was “time for it to die,” Rubio mumbled some lame words: “There are things that USAID, that we do through USAID, that we should continue to do, and we will continue to do. This is not about ending the programs that USAID does, per se.” Not per se, but per fact. Say it with me: Rubio could have done the right thing but let it pass.

The secretary of state is considered the premier cabinet post: The secretary is the nation’s chief diplomat, is fourth in the presidential succession and is often the president’s chief foreign policy advisor. Rubio, as both secretary of state and national security advisor, ought to dominate this administration’s foreign policy as no single advisor has since Kissinger. But Rubio could not dissuade Trump from threatening to invade the territory of one of our closest allies, nor from menacing Canada, Mexico, Cuba, Panama and Colombia. Rubio was effectively by Trump’s side on “Liberation Day,” when Trump declared a trade war on the entire world, and was an active participant in the decision to invade and plunder Venezuela. In fact, it was Rubio who strutted and boasted after the fact, “Don’t play games with this president when he’s in office, because it’s not going to turn out well.” What must have been going through his mind when Trump announced, at a post-Maduro-snatch press conference, that Rubio would henceforth be running Venezuela? It must have been unprintable. Rubio could have done the right thing …

In the last two years, the U.S. military has conducted something like 68 extrajudicial strikes on suspected drug-smuggling boats in the Pacific and Caribbean — including on vessels that were not suspected of carrying drugs or weapons — resulting in about 230 fatalities. At least some of those deaths were “double tap” strikes of people clinging to wreckage, which violates the Geneva Conventions and our own laws. It’s premeditated murder. Previous secretaries of state have resigned on principle for far less. Rubio could have done …

Rubio may have wished to disappear into the sofa cushions when Trump and Vance humiliated Volodymyr Zelensky in an Oval Office beatdown that should live in infamy, but he failed to defend our beleaguered ally and instead piled on, saying later that Zelensky needed to apologize.

He failed to prevent Trump from undertaking a war on Iran that was the most impulsive, least well-considered act of the dumbest president in history.

Well, you may say, it’s not Rubio’s fault that he worked for such a fool. But yes, it very much is. And by so doing he has forfeited the right to be considered for any future role in American government.

Mona Charen is policy editor of The Bulwark and host of the “Beg to Differ” podcast. Her book, “Hard Right: The GOP’s Drift Toward Extremism,” is available now.